Skip to main content

Table 9 Overview of expansion planning models in power system

From: An overview of inertia requirement in modern renewable energy sourced grid: challenges and way forward

Objectives

Constraints

Types of uncertainties

Model framework

Expansion planning model

Solver/software/system configuration

Inertia Consideration

Refs.

Minimize cost comprising operating, investment, and environmental costs

Unit commitment and DC-Optimal power flow (OPC) constraints

Not Considered (NC)

Deterministic MILP

GTEP

CPLEX 12.9.0.0. solver.:2.67 GHz processor and 64 GB RAM

No

[36]

Minimize emission, and maximize profit

Operational constraints

Varying capacity of wind turbine

LP

GTEP

CPLEX solver in GAMS. Core i5,3 GHz processor and 16 GB of RAM

No

[140]

Minimize cost, energy losses, and voltage violation

DC-OPF

NC

MILP

GEP

CPLEX solver in GAMS. Intel Core i7-4770 processor

No

[143]

Minimize investment costs

DC-OPF

NC

MILP

GTEP

LINPROG function in MATLAB and CPLEX Solver in GAMS. 2.5 GHz CPU, Core i5 and 4- GB memory

No

[44]

Minimize cost, and energy not supplied (ENS)

DC-OPF,

N-1 constraints

NC

MILP

TEP

CPLEX Solver in GAMS. Core-i7,

2.81-GHz processor and 16-GB RAM

No

[46]

Minimizing cost

DC-OPF

Load demand

Stochastic two-stage MILP optimization model

GSTEP

NG

No

[47]

Minimize investment, maintenance, and CO2 emission cost

AC–OPF and renewable energy policy constraints

Load demand and RES variations

MINLP

TGSEP

Accelerated Benders Dual Decomposition algorithm

No

[48]

Minimize cost and energy not served (ENS)

Security and resilience constraints

NC

MILP

TEP

Benders Decomposition algorithm

No

[49]

Minimize cost and emission

N-1 contingency constraints

PV generation and load variations

Scenario-based stochastic MILP

IEGNEP

CPLEX’s solver in GAMS 25.1.2

1.60 GHz CPU; core i7 and 4 GB memory

No

[51]

Minimize cost and carbon emission

Generation and transmission limits, ramp constraints

load demand variations

Deterministic MILP

GTEP

Branch:and bound method and weighted sum bisection method (WSBM)

No

[52]

Minimize cost

Reliability constraints

NC

Multi-level game theory model

GEP

Game theory and bi-level modeling in MATLAB. 8 GB RAM computer

No

[124, 144]

Minimize cost and CO2 emission

AC–OPF

Load demand and generation variations

MINLP

DSEP

CPLEX solver using the branch-and-bound algorithm

No

[54]

Minimize investment, operation, and transmission service cost

DC-OPF

Nil

MILP

GTEP

BONMIN solver in GAMS

No

[37]

Minimize the investment costs while considering system uncertainties

DC-OPF

NC

MILP

DSEP

Gurobi solver in Python.:8 cores and 32 GB of RAM

No

[56]

Minimize investment and operational cost

Ramping, DC-DC-OPF constraints

Water flow variations

LP

GEP

Progressive Hedging Algorithm (PHA) and Gurobi 7.0 solver in Python

24-core computer and 32 GB RAM

No

[145]