Power output (MW) | Compared algorithms | Proposed algorithms | Â | Compared algorithms | Proposed algorithms | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | MTVPSO | MPSO | DHS | aDE | aPSO | haDEPSO |  | MTVPSO | MPSO | DHS | aDE | aPSO | haDEPSO |
1 | 116.2518 | 116.2514 | 119.0000 | 116.2528 | 116.2418 | 116.2528 | 71 | 143.3803 | 143.3803 | 500.0000 | 143.4785 | 143.8778 | 143.3804 |
2 | 188.8395 | 188.8395 | 119.0000 | 188.8345 | 188.8295 | 188.8375 | 72 | 388.3236 | 388.3236 | 500.0000 | 388.3785 | 388.1248 | 388.7854 |
3 | 189.9734 | 189.9734 | 164.0000 | 189.9724 | 189.9834 | 189.9734 | 73 | 202.9482 | 202.9482 | 241.0000 | 202.7785 | 202.7854 | 202.1245 |
4 | 189.8984 | 189.8984 | 164.0000 | 189.8974 | 189.8984 | 189.8974 | 74 | 176.0783 | 176.0783 | 241.0000 | 176.0785 | 176.0745 | 176.7854 |
5 | 168.6455 | 168.6455 | 190.0000 | 168.6445 | 168.6655 | 168.6455 | 75 | 175.8523 | 175.8523 | 241.0000 | 175.8785 | 175.8545 | 175.4561 |
6 | 187.3990 | 187.3990 | 190.0000 | 187.394 | 187.389 | 187.391 | 76 | 177.8040 | 177.8040 | 241.0000 | 177.8874 | 177.8045 | 177.8125 |
7 | 489.9976 | 489.9976 | 190.0000 | 489.9946 | 489.9976 | 489.9977 | 77 | 179.5410 | 179.5410 | 774.0000 | 179.5254 | 179.5411 | 179.4856 |
8 | 489.8645 | 489.8645 | 190.0000 | 489.8645 | 489.8745 | 489.8645 | 78 | 330.6797 | 330.6797 | 774.0000 | 330.6258 | 330.6745 | 330.6785 |
9 | 495.9917 | 495.9917 | 168.5398 | 495.9997 | 495.9817 | 495.9918 | 79 | 530.9939 | 530.9939 | 769.0000 | 530.9358 | 530.9488 | 530.9987 |
10 | 495.9000 | 495.9000 | 168.5398 | 495.904 | 495.91 | 495.7854 | 80 | 530.9852 | 530.9852 | 769.0000 | 530.9154 | 530.9878 | 530.9258 |
11 | 495.9999 | 495.9999 | 190.0000 | 495.9949 | 495.9299 | 495.7896 | 81 | 260.0529 | 260.0529 | 3.0000 | 260.0535 | 260.0787 | 260.7854 |
12 | 495.9418 | 495.9418 | 190.0000 | 495.9408 | 495.9318 | 495.9408 | 82 | 56.04720 | 56.0472 | 82 3.0000 | 56.04715 | 56.04748 | 56.07854 |
13 | 505.9503 | 505.9503 | 490.0000 | 505.9513 | 505.9803 | 505.9513 | 83 | 115.2868 | 115.2868 | 83 3.0000 | 115.2154 | 115.2487 | 115.2987 |
14 | 508.9842 | 508.9842 | 490.0000 | 508.9832 | 508.9242 | 508.9822 | 84 | 115.0050 | 115.0050 | 84 3.0000 | 115.0785 | 115.1452 | 115.1545 |
15 | 505.9854 | 505.9854 | 490.0000 | 505.9844 | 505.9454 | 505.9814 | 85 | 115.3836 | 115.3836 | 250.0000 | 115.3834 | 115.3987 | 115.3886 |
16 | 504.9535 | 504.9535 | 490.0000 | 504.9525 | 504.9435 | 504.9635 | 86 | 207.0000 | 207.0000 | 250.0000 | 207.0788 | 207.0078 | 207.0000 |
17 | 505.9841 | 505.9841 | 496.0000 | 505.9881 | 505.9941 | 505.9741 | 87 | 207.0965 | 207.0965 | 250.0000 | 207.0985 | 207.0965 | 207.0785 |
18 | 505.9365 | 505.9365 | 496.0000 | 505.9365 | 505.9265 | 505.9465 | 88 | 175.1027 | 175.1027 | 250.0000 | 175.1078 | 175.1125 | 175.1485 |
19 | 504.9788 | 504.9788 | 496.0000 | 504.9748 | 504.9688 | 504.9888 | 89 | 175.1656 | 175.1656 | 250.0000 | 175.1678 | 175.1145 | 175.1678 |
20 | 504.9618 | 504.9618 | 496.0000 | 504.9628 | 504.9718 | 504.9418 | 90 | 182.1361 | 182.1361 | 250.0000 | 182.1354 | 182.1361 | 182.1378 |
21 | 504.9769 | 504.9769 | 496.0000 | 504.9779 | 504.9869 | 504.9369 | 91 | 175.1669 | 175.1669 | 250.0000 | 175.1678 | 175.1785 | 175.1754 |
22 | 504.9081 | 504.9081 | 496.0000 | 504.9091 | 504.9281 | 504.9181 | 92 | 579.9855 | 579.9855 | 250.0000 | 579.9854 | 579.9452 | 579.9785 |
23 | 504.9514 | 504.9514 | 496.0000 | 504.9524 | 504.9614 | 504.9814 | 93 | 645.0000 | 645.0000 | 250.0000 | 645.0999 | 645.0089 | 645.0754 |
24 | 504.9742 | 504.9742 | 496.0000 | 504.9742 | 504.9442 | 504.9642 | 94 | 983.9400 | 983.9400 | 250.0000 | 983.9485 | 983.9200 | 983.9487 |
25 | 536.9944 | 536.9944 | 506.0000 | 536.9934 | 536.9844 | 536.9844 | 95 | 977.9925 | 977.9925 | 250.000 | 977.9978 | 977.9785 | 977.9925 |
26 | 536.9804 | 536.9804 | 506.0000 | 536.9814 | 536.9704 | 536.9704 | 96 | 681.9838 | 681.9838 | 250.0000 | 681.9825 | 681.9025 | 681.9895 |
27 | 548.9866 | 548.9866 | 509.0000 | 548.9867 | 548.9666 | 548.9466 | 97 | 719.9953 | 719.9953 | 250.0000 | 719.9985 | 719.9954 | 719.9975 |
28 | 548.9698 | 548.9698 | 509.0000 | 548.9699 | 548.9498 | 548.9398 | 98 | 718.0000 | 718.0000 | 250.0000 | 718.0897 | 718.0854 | 718.0045 |
29 | 500.9609 | 500.9609 | 506.0000 | 500.9604 | 500.9309 | 500.9509 | 99 | 719.9553 | 719.9553 | 250.0000 | 719.9558 | 719.9785 | 719.9553 |
30 | 500.8584 | 500.8584 | 506.0000 | 500.8585 | 500.8984 | 500.8484 | 100 | 963.8138 | 963.8138 | 250.0000 | 963.8145 | 963.825 | 963.8125 |
31 | 505.9982 | 505.9982 | 505.0000 | 505.9987 | 505.9482 | 505.8982 | 101 | 957.9252 | 957.9252 | 165.0000 | 957.9285 | 957.9152 | 957.9245 |
32 | 505.9890 | 505.9890 | 505.0000 | 505.9899 | 505.999 | 505.889 | 102 | 1006.9391 | 1006.9391 | 165.0000 | 1006.9381 | 1006.9321 | 1006.9311 |
33 | 505.9872 | 505.9872 | 506.0000 | 505.9472 | 505.9472 | 505.8872 | 103 | 1005.9547 | 1005.9547 | 165.0000 | 1010.5031 | 1005.9547 | 1005.9547 |
34 | 505.8398 | 505.8398 | 506.0000 | 505.8394 | 505.8398 | 505.9398 | 104 | 1012.9951 | 1012.9951 | 165.0000 | 1012.9981 | 1012.9971 | 1012.9781 |
35 | 499.9759 | 499.9759 | 506.0000 | 499.9554 | 499.9759 | 499.8759 | 105 | 1019.9532 | 1019.9532 | 165.0000 | 1019.9512 | 1019.9512 | 1019.9572 |
36 | 499.8309 | 499.8309 | 506.0000 | 499.7854 | 499.8801 | 499.8325 | 106 | 953.9784 | 953.9784 | 165.0000 | 953.9785 | 953.9784 | 953.9778 |
37 | 240.9712 | 240.9712 | 505.0000 | 240.8454 | 240.9718 | 240.9745 | 107 | 951.9893 | 951.9893 | 165.0000 | 951.9847 | 951.9893 | 951.9898 |
38 | 240.9668 | 240.9668 | 505.0000 | 280.9596 | 240.9668 | 240.9154 | 108 | 1005.9502 | 1005.9502 | 165.0000 | 1005.957 | 1005.9502 | 1005.9522 |
39 | 773.9998 | 773.9998 | 505.0000 | 773.9154 | 773.9198 | 773.9896 | 109 | 1012.9827 | 1012.9827 | 180.0000 | 1012.9847 | 1012.9827 | 1012.9828 |
40 | 768.9143 | 768.9143 | 505.0000 | 768.9154 | 767.9123 | 768.9145 | 110 | 1020.9864 | 1020.9864 | 180.0000 | 1020.9874 | 1020.9864 | 1020.9887 |
41 | 3.484200 | 3.4842 | 505.0000 | 3.484295 | 3.984201 | 3.48422 | 111 | 1014.9943 | 1014.9943 | 180.0000 | 1014.9973 | 1014.9943 | 1014.9987 |
42 | 3.027400 | 3.0274 | 505.0000 | 3.027444 | 3.087478 | 3.027401 | 112 | 94.03550 | 94.0355 | 180.0000 | 94.78569 | 94.0355 | 94.035485 |
43 | 186.7539 | 186.7539 | 505.0000 | 186. 9636 | 186.5847 | 186.7525 | 113 | 94.03730 | 94.0373 | 103.0000 | 132.0374 | 94.0373 | 94.037378 |
44 | 216.9286 | 216.9286 | 505.0000 | 216.9255 | 216.4896 | 216.9287 | 114 | 94.01730 | 94.0173 | 103.0000 | 94.25732 | 94.0173 | 94.017325 |
45 | 249.3928 | 249.3928 | 505.0000 | 298.3924 | 249.2541 | 249.3928 | 115 | 244.3547 | 244.3547 | 198.0000 | 244.3547 | 244.3547 | 244.35474 |
46 | 249.9292 | 249.9292 | 505.0000 | 249.9299 | 249.4856 | 249.9293 | 116 | 244.0590 | 244.0590 | 198.0000 | 244.159 | 244.059 | 244.05902 |
47 | 246.5461 | 246.5461 | 505.0000 | 246.5445 | 246.1596 | 246.5458 | 117 | 244.1444 | 244.1444 | 312.0000 | 289.1844 | 244.1444 | 241.7985 |
48 | 248.6987 | 248.6987 | 505.0000 | 248.7854 | 248.6562 | 248.6785 | 118 | 95.32550 | 95.3255 | 312.0000 | 95.3215 | 95.3255 | 95.32458 |
49 | 248.7121 | 248.7121 | 537.0000 | 248.7854 | 248.7486 | 248.7485 | 119 | 95.01860 | 95.0186 | 308.5679 | 95.0166 | 95.0186 | 95.01848 |
50 | 248.8088 | 248.8088 | 537.0000 | 248.2541 | 248.7854 | 248.8052 | 120 | 116.1636 | 116.1636 | 308.5881 | 116.1536 | 116.1636 | 116.1645 |
51 | 166.6126 | 166.6126 | 537.0000 | 166.1548 | 166.8526 | 166.6115 | 121 | 175.0352 | 175.0352 | 163.0000 | 175.0152 | 175.0352 | 175.0351 |
52 | 165.0625 | 165.0625 | 537.0000 | 165.8651 | 165.7425 | 165.0156 | 122 | 2.00640 | 2.0064 | 163.0000 | 2.00646 | 2.0064 | 2.00645 |
53 | 169.5018 | 169.5018 | 549.0000 | 169.8745 | 169.8918 | 169.5785 | 123 | 4.04020 | 4.0402 | 95.0000 | 4.84021 | 4.0402 | 4.04022 |
54 | 166.3101 | 166.3101 | 549.0000 | 166.9658 | 166.3101 | 166.3125 | 124 | 15.0993 | 15.0993 | 95.0000 | 15.8992 | 15.0993 | 15.0993 |
55 | 180.0956 | 180.0956 | 549.0000 | 180.0956 | 180.7856 | 180.0154 | 125 | 9.00550 | 9.0055 | 511.0000 | 9.9755 | 9.0055 | 9.00555 |
56 | 180.2748 | 180.2748 | 549.0000 | 180.2254 | 180.7848 | 180.2715 | 126 | 12.0655 | 12.0655 | 511.0000 | 12.0555 | 12.0655 | 12.0654 |
57 | 103.1771 | 103.1771 | 501.0000 | 103.1741 | 103.1521 | 103.1715 | 127 | 10.0080 | 10.0080 | 511.0000 | 10.018 | 10.008 | 10.0084 |
58 | 198.1757 | 198.1757 | 501.0000 | 198.1351 | 198.7847 | 198.1745 | 128 | 112.0382 | 112.0382 | 511.0000 | 111.4382 | 112.0382 | 112.038 |
59 | 309.9475 | 309.9475 | 499.0000 | 309.9874 | 309.9985 | 309.9479 | 129 | 4.08120 | 4.0812 | 490.0000 | 4.7852 | 4.0812 | 4.08123 |
60 | 293.8267 | 293.8267 | 499.0000 | 293.8895 | 293.8157 | 293.8214 | 130 | 5.02750 | 5.0275 | 490.0000 | 5.9255 | 5.0275 | 5.0275 |
61 | 163.5888 | 163.5888 | 506.0000 | 163.5147 | 163.5898 | 163.5145 | 131 | 5.05170 | 5.0517 | 256.7772 | 5.0557 | 5.0517 | 5.05145 |
62 | 95.30030 | 95.3003 | 506.0000 | 95.30454 | 95.3014 | 95.30152 | 132 | 50.1071 | 50.1071 | 256.7802 | 50.9171 | 50.1071 | 50.1458 |
63 | 168.1584 | 168.1584 | 506.0000 | 168.1785 | 168.1244 | 168.1598 | 133 | 5.04680 | 5.0468 | 490.0000 | 5.0468 | 5.0468 | 5.78542 |
64 | 166.0715 | 166.0715 | 506.0000 | 166.0701 | 166.0725 | 166.0025 | 134 | 42.0244 | 42.0244 | 490.0000 | 42.9244 | 42.0244 | 42.0785 |
65 | 486.8818 | 486.8818 | 506.0000 | 486.8458 | 486.8808 | 486.8085 | 135 | 42.0341 | 42.0341 | 490.0000 | 42.9331 | 42.0341 | 42.2548 |
66 | 205.5539 | 205.5539 | 506.0000 | 205.7889 | 205.5529 | 205.5025 | 136 | 41.0343 | 41.0343 | 490.0000 | 41.9343 | 41.0343 | 41.7854 |
67 | 483.1274 | 483.1274 | 506.0000 | 483.1984 | 483.1324 | 483.1215 | 137 | 17.0443 | 17.0443 | 130.0000 | 17.9453 | 16.1243 | 17.7869 |
68 | 486.0292 | 486.0292 | 506.0000 | 486.1442 | 486.1522 | 486.0785 | 138 | 7.14970 | 7.1497 | 130.0000 | 7.1498 | 7.1497 | 7.14948 |
69 | 130.2962 | 130.2962 | 500.0000 | 130.2542 | 130.2252 | 130.2902 | 139 | 7.02920 | 7.0292 | 339.4395 | 7.0291 | 7.0292 | 7.02921 |
70 | 339.3610 | 339.3610 | 500.0000 | 339.3055 | 339.314 | 339.3678 | 140 | 26.4594 | 26.4594 | 339.4395 | 26.4894 | 26.4594 | 26.4684 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  | Total power (MW) | 49,342.000 | 49,342 | 49,342 | 49,342.000 | 49,342.000 | 49,342.000 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  | Min cost ($/h) | 1,560,436.71 | 1,560,436.0 | 1,657,944.8622 | 1,560,436.76 | 1,560,435.88 | 1,560,434.54 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  | Mean cost ($/h) | 1,560,446.22 | 1,560,445.0 | 1,657,944.8627 | 1,560,445.43 | 1,560,444.56 | 1,560,440.32 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  | Max cost ($/h) | 1,560,460.55 | 1,560,462.0 | 1,657,944.8652 | 1,560,461.66 | 1,560,461.52 | 1,560,460.89 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  | Std. of cost ($/h) | 0.00003 | 0.000458 | 0.0005 | 0.0000054 | 0.0000076 | 0.0000003 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  | CPU mean time (s) | 17.03 | 18.43 | 4.6 | 5.66 | 5.98 | 3.98 |